Skip Navigation

Developing an Analysis of Threats to Voting SystemsOctober 7, 2005   Gaithersburg, MDNIST - National Institute of Standards and Technology

 

 

Home

Agenda

Contact

System Definitions

Submit Material

View Threat Papers


Speaker Presentations

Listen to Workshop Proceedings
 

Other NIST Voting Work

   

Direct Recording Electronic (DRE) Devices
 

Direct Recording Electronic (DRE) voting systems directly record the voter’s selections in each race or contest on the ballot in electronic form. Such systems can be compared with mechanical lever voting machines, which directly record votes on mechanical counters inside the machine. Neither DREs nor lever voting machines create a tangible physical record of the voter's selections on a physical ballot. Typical DRE machines have flat panel display screens with touch-screen input, although other display technologies have been used, including print on paper, and other input technologies have been used, such as push buttons. The defining characteristic of these machines is that votes are captured electronically and stored in that form. Such machines may print a durable paper record of the votes cast, for example, after the polls are closed or on an internal printer, but this record is not subject to voter verification. DRE machines also record event logs giving the time of each significant operation on the machine, such as when it was set up for an election, when the polls were opened, when the polls were closed, and when a ballot was cast (but not which ballot was cast then). At the close of polls, vote totals, the event log, and all votes cast may be printed. In addition, electronic records of these may be extracted from the machine (for example, on removable media such as disks or compact electronic memory modules), or the records may be transmitted electronically to a vote collection center (for example, by modem). Procedures for using these alternatives vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. Typically, the electronic transmission or the electronic memory module is delivered to a central vote-counting system (for example, in the county election headquarters), where jurisdiction-wide totals are computed.


There are three subtypes of DRE, based on the style of user interfaces/interaction:

  • The touch screen DRE. These systems use a touch screen to collect user input when not in an audio ballot mode.
  • The full-face DRE. These DRE systems generally involve electro-mechanical human interface using switches providing tactile feedback to the voter, and have no paging.
  • DRE with off-screen mechanical control in which the user views options displayed on a screen but provides input via buttons, switches, dials or other input devices.
     

Software is updated in DRE systems via various methods, specific to each voting system. In general, software updating involves someone (a technician or election official representative) installing new software over older software typically using whatever medium the DRE uses to transport votes or, in some cases, laptop computers with special software running on them provided by the vendors. One or a small number of DREs later function as a Ballot Definition System, producing election definition files which are installed in the DREs generally at a county warehouse facility. (Note that some DREs require a stand-alone PC to do ballot programming.)
 


View a document describing scenario assumptions for other voting device types.

View an all-in-one document describing the four primary voting device types.

Other voting device types:

 

Page created August 2005
Last updated: Aug 13, 2007
Web site point of contact

Privacy policy / security notice / accessibility statement
Disclaimer / FOIA
NIST is an agency of the U.S. Commerce Department